Contact Jacqueline DeMontravel

Send a message directly to the publisher

Beyond Public vs. Private: Finding the Right Fit for Your Child

Back to Articles
Share:
  • Copied!

Many parents come to realize that, from September through June, their child may spend more waking hours in a school community than they do at home. While that thought could initially feel quite daunting, across Fairfield County—and certainly here in Darien—we are fortunate to have outstanding public schools alongside a number of remarkable independent schools, each capable of becoming a meaningful extension of home. 

That is not something every community can say, and it is one of this region’s greatest strengths. 

Each fall brings the promise of a new school year, along with a range of emotions that come with parenting: from our highest aspirations for our children to the worries that keep us up at night. As the year unfolds and children navigate different paths forward, many parents may find themselves pausing to ask a version of the same question: 

“How do we know if a public or independent school is right for our child?”

As families begin the journey of exploring an independent school, they are undoubtedly curious and often seek guidance from schools to make the “right” decision. 

When parents ask me whether they should choose a public or an independent school, I frequently suggest that they begin by thinking deeply about the child they know today and the person they hope their child will become. That typically leads to a different, and, we believe, more important question:

Greens Farms Academy science fair

Westport, CT, United States — Greens Farms Academy in Westport, CT on Tuesday, May 12, 2026. (Photo by Yoon S. Byun) © 2026 Strewn Wonder, LLC

What kind of environment will help my child flourish and become the best version of themselves?

No two children are exactly alike. They learn differently, develop at different rates, discover passions in different ways and benefit from different kinds of relationships. The school that allows one child to thrive may not be the same environment that brings out the very best in another.

The decision, then, is less about comparing schools and more about understanding our children.

Some students flourish in large, vibrant school communities with extensive course offerings, broad extracurricular opportunities and deep neighborhood connections. Others find that they thrive in smaller learning environments where they are known by every teacher, where classes invite frequent discussion and where relationships become the foundation for both academic growth and personal confidence.

Neither experience is inherently better. They are simply different, and children are different, too. That is why “fit” matters. 

As parents consider school choice, a great deal of attention naturally goes to curriculum, facilities, technology and college outcomes. While each of those matters, I’ve come to believe that families should take the time to ask the following:

  • Does my child feel known?
  • Where do they find confidence?
  • What kind of challenges inspire them rather than discourage them?
  • Who are the adults who will notice when they are struggling—or when they are ready for more?
  • How does this school define success?
  • Are the school’s values aligned with our family’s values?

The answers to those questions often reveal more than any ranking or statistic ever could.

Greens Farms Academy young kids class

Westport, CT, United States — Greens Farms Academy in Westport, CT on Wednesday, May 13, 2026. (Photo by Yoon S. Byun) © 2026 Strewn Wonder, LLC

One of the great privileges of my role in an independent school is the opportunity to collaborate with colleagues across many educational settings. Public and independent schools have far more in common than they sometimes receive credit for. Both are filled with talented educators who care deeply about young people. Both are adapting to a rapidly changing world shaped by new technologies, evolving expectations and increasingly complex questions about how children learn, connect and grow.

And in many ways, we are all working toward the same goal: preparing young people not simply for college or careers, but for lives of purpose, curiosity, resilience and contribution. That shared purpose matters.

Education should never feel like a competition between sectors. Our communities are strongest when families have meaningful choices and when schools learn from one another. Innovation, thoughtful teaching and a commitment to students exist in both public and independent education. We all benefit when we recognize those strengths and continue working together on behalf of children.

Ultimately, choosing a school is not about finding the “best” school.

It is about finding the right place, at the right time, for a particular child.

When families shift their thinking from comparison to fit, the conversation changes. It becomes less about labels and more about possibility. Because in the end, that is what education has always been about: helping every child discover an environment where they are challenged, supported, known and inspired to become the fullest version of themselves.

Any content, resident submissions, guest columns, advertisements, and advertorials are not necessarily endorsed by or represent the views of Best Version Media LLC (BVM) or any municipality, homeowners associations, businesses, or organizations that this publication serves. BVM is not responsible for the reliability, suitability, or timeliness of any content submitted, inclusive of materials generated or composed through artificial intelligence (AI). All content submitted is done so at the sole discretion of the submitting party.

Meet the Publisher

Other Publications

Other
Publications

Contact Us